Jerry I wonder if this is a lead that might help you: Apparently some Loyalists were re-settled at New Carlisle and they included a Robert Caldwell from Ireland. These Caldwell's were married into the Beebe family and had relations at Niagara. I am wondering whether your "Suzanne Baby" was from the same family but just another spelling. Vintages, places and political loyalties are very similar and the letter below is a distinct connection between the two places. If you check my blog - you will find there is even an Australian connection back to New Carlisle

"Transcription of the Letter of Andrew and Sarah Beebe Caldwell to Adin Beebe, 23 Sep 1809
Andrew and Sarah Caldwell of New Carlisle, Bonaventure Co., Quebec wrote this letter to Sarah's uncle, Adin Beebe, in Niagara--near St. Catharines--Ontario with the primary purpose of determining the living and economic conditions in the Niagara area, in anticipation of a possible move there because of the "Rachad State of the Districk of the Gaspe." [There is an indication on the original transcription that the letter was dictated to Amasa Beebe by Andrew and Sarah.]"

http://www.chaleurgenealogy.beyondgrandmasattic.com/CaldwellLetter.html

Tom

Jerry,

You might have missed my post in reply - you should be very interested in this family as they may well be related to your William Caldwell (and they had Beleek - Castle Caldwell associations!)

Tom